Ayn Rand and Martial Arts: Barrowman on Bruce Lee
JARS contributor, colleague, and friend, Kyle Barrowman, has written a
provocative new piece, "Bruce Lee and the Perfection of Martial Arts (Studies):
An Exercise in Alterdisciplinarity." Here is the abstract to
the article:
This essay builds from an analysis of the philosophical underpinnings of Bruce
Lee's jeet kune do to an analysis of the current state of academic scholarship
generally and martial arts studies scholarship specifically. For the sake of a
more comprehensive understanding of the philosophical underpinnings of jeet kune
do, and in particular its affinities with a philosophical tradition traced by
Stanley Cavell under the heading of perfectionism, this essay brings the
philosophical writings of Ralph Waldo Emerson and Ayn Rand into contact with
Lee's writings during the time that he spent formulating his martial arts
philosophy. Additionally, this essay uses the philosophical insights of Emerson,
Rand, and Lee to challenge longstanding academic dogma vis-a-vis
poststructuralist philosophy, the methods of academic intervention, and the
nature of philosophical argumentation. Though pitched as a debate regarding the
content and the status of Bruce Lee and his combative philosophy, this essay
endeavors to inspire scholars to (re)examine their conceptions of Bruce Lee,
martial arts, and martial arts studies.
The article appears in the latest edition of Martial
Arts Studies, hosted by Cardiff University Press, devoted to
"Bruce Lee's Martial Legacies" and is co-edited by Kyle. In his contribution, he
brings Bruce Lee together with Ayn Rand and Ralph Waldo Emerson---while taking a
few additional jabs at poststructuralism, as he's done in such articles as
"Philosophical Problems in Contemporary Art Criticism: Objectivism,
Poststructuralism, and the Axiom of Authorship" and "The Future of Art
Criticism: Objectivism Goes to the Movies," which appeared in the December
2017 and December
2018 issues, respectively, of The
Journal of Ayn Rand Studies
What is of particular interest about Kyle's essay is how he highlights Rand's
relationship to a philosophical tradition of perfectionism (which, of course,
has Aristotelian roots) and his view of Ralph Waldo Emerson as an ally of
Objectivist philosophy. Folks can download the article here [pdf
link].
Posted by chris at 11:33 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Culture | Rand
Studies
Song of the Day #1708
Song of the Day: Old
Town Road (Remix), words
and music by Kiowa
Roukema and Montero
Hill (aka Lil
Nas X) with a sampled
beat from "34
Ghosts IV" [YouTube link] by Nine
Inch Nails (credited to the
Oscar-winning duo of Trent
Reznor and Atticus
Ross), breaks
the all-time Billboard Hot 100 record today, logging its seventeenth
straight week at #1. It passes both "Despacito"
(by Luis
Fonsi and Daddy
Yankee, featuring Justin
Bieber) and "One
Sweet Day" (by Mariah
Carey and Boys
II Men), each of which held the previous #1 record at sixteen
consecutive weeks. Lil
Nas X paid $30 for the right to use the
Nine Inch Nails sample and added Billy
Ray Cyrus to the performance, producing one of the most interesting
crossover sounds, merging elements of country, rock, and rap. And I'm just going
to say it: Whoever dreamed that a song that started as a meme [YouTube
link], which went viral, featuring the
57-year old country-singing father of Miley
Cyrus and the
20-year old African American rapper who recently came out would be the
longest running #1 single in the history of the Billboard Hot 100 charts?
Goes to show you---life offers us a rainbow of possibilities! But it helps if
your song is really catchy. Check out the
mini-movie video version of the song [YouTube link] (with
some hilarious cameos) and the truly infectious single
version [YouTube link].
Song of the Day #1707
Song of the Day: We
Shall Overcome is a gospel song descended from a 1900 hymn by Charles
Albert Tindley and other African American spirituals. It was sung by
many folk singers, such as Pete
Seeger, Frank
Hamilton, Joe
Glazer, and others, as a protest song during the civil rights era.
But it was the Staten
Island-born Joan
Baez, who had first met and befriended Martin
Luther King, Jr. back in 1956, that would become most associated with
this song. A civil rights and antiwar activist, she sang it at the 1963
March on Washington, near the base of the Lincoln
Memorial, in front of 300,000 people. During her set at Woodstock,
the visibly pregnant Baez spoke
eloquently about how her husband at the time, David
Harris, who opposed
conscription [YouTube link to a Johnny
Carson interview with Ayn
Rand, who opposed
both the draft and the Vietnam War], was arrested, convicted, and
imprisoned for draft evasion in July 1969. (He would later be paroled in October
1970). So it was no coincidence that she'd
close her own Woodstock set with this song [YouTube link] in the wee
hours of Saturday, August 16, 1969.
Posted by chris at 12:05 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Music | Politics
(Theory, History, Now) | Rand
Studies | Remembrance
Song of the Day #1706
Song of the Day: Let's
Get Loud, words
and music by Gloria
Estefan and Kike
Santander, was featured on Jennifer
Lopez's 1999 debut album, "On
the 6." Though the song was not released officially as a single, it
was a Top 40 hit on the Hot
Dance Club Play chart. Today, the Bronx-born Jenny from the block,
like Woodstock---a child of 1969---turns 50
years old! Check out the
album version and remixes by Kung
Pow, Castle
Hill, and D.MD
Strong [YouTube links].
Posted by chris at 01:03 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Music | Remembrance
Baseball Hall of Fame: Mo and More
I just finished watching the live MLB broadcast of the Baseball
Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony of the 2019
inductees into Cooperstown. It is very difficult for any baseball fan
to watch a ceremony like this and not be moved or sometimes brought to tears by
the presentations, speeches, and various tributes. And this year was no
exception.
The 2019 inductees included: the late Roy
Halladay, Edgar
Martinez, Mike
Mussina, and Mariano
"Mo" Rivera, along with "game era inductees" Harold
Baines and Lee
Smith.
Former New York Yankee outfielder, Bernie
Williams, opened up the ceremonies with an instrumental rendition of
"The
Star Spangled Banner" on guitar (see here [YouTube
link]). And he also provided us with a sweet guitar rendition of "Take
Me Out to the Ballgame" (with a touch of "Enter
Sandman") before Mo took the stage. Indeed, by the time Mariano
Rivera reached the podium, as the last person honored today, with the
other three members of the Core Four present (who won five World Series between
1996 and 2009)---Jorge
Posada, Andy
Pettitte, and Derek
Jeter---well, there wasn't a dry eye left in the Sciabarra household.
I was privileged to see Mo
throw his wicked cut fastball to record just a few of his 652 regular
season saves (not to mention 42 postseason saves) when I traveled to the old
Yankee Stadium some years ago. I am delighted to have seen him enter the Hall of
Fame in his first year of eligibility, the only baseball player to have ever
been selected
unanimously by the Baseball Writers Association of America. You did
good, Mo, and you once again "closed out" a sporting event with a touch of
class.
Posted by chris at 04:46 PM | Permalink |
Posted to Remembrance | Sports
Song of the Day #1705
Song of the Day: Moon
Maiden, words and music by Edward
Kennedy "Duke" Ellington, was commissioned by the ABC
News Network to debut on the day of the Apollo
11 moon
landing and moon walk. Awaiting the
first walk upon the surface of the moon by Neil
Armstrong and Buzz
Aldrin, while Michael
Collins orbited above in "Columbia,"
the command
module, ABC anchor Frank
Reynolds introduced the piece. This performance by Duke was
actually recorded live on 15 July 2019 but aired on the ABC network on this date
fifty years ago, after the lunar
module, "Eagle,"
touched down in the Sea
of Tranquility. Check out the rare footage of its debut by Duke
Ellington and a
later studio recording [YouTube links] with Duke "speaking"
the lyrics, accompanied by his own playing on the vibes-sounding celeste.
As a 9-year old kid, I cannot even begin to describe the level of utter elation
I felt watching the grainy images of human beings on the surface of a celestial
body other than the Earth. I had followed the space program from the earliest
moments of my consciousness of such things (the politics of
it never crossed my mind at the time); I remembered John
Glenn's orbit around the earth, the
Apollo 1 fire, and the
Christmas Eve moon orbit of Apollo 8. But nothing could compare to
the excitement I felt watching my
TV fifty years ago this day [YouTube link], the sense of awe I felt
hearing Neil
Armstrong's first words on the lunar surface, and the sense of hope
that was inspired in me, hearing him enunciate the words on the lunar
plaque: "We
came in peace for all mankind" [YouTube link]. It gave credence to Robert
Browning's poetic tribute to human potential: "Ah,
but a man's reach should exceed his grasp, Or what's a heaven for?"
The promise of that which seemed impossible made real inspired me to use that
line from "Andrea
del Sarto" as an epigraph to Marx,
Hayek, and Utopia, the first book in my "Dialectics
and Liberty Trilogy."
Posted by chris at 12:05 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Culture | Music | Periodicals | Politics
(Theory, History, Now) | Remembrance
Song of the Day #1704
Song of the Day: Dark
Star, lyrics by Robert
Hunter, music by the lead guitarist of the Grateful
Dead, Jerry
Garcia and his bandmates, is best remembered in its
23+ minute rendition [YouTube link] from their 1969 live album, "Live/Dead,"
which blended psychedelia, jazz, and jam elements. By contrast, the original single
version, at 2 minutes and 44 seconds [YouTube link] sold only 500
copies and "sank like a stone," as band member Phil
Lesh put it. The song was also a
respectable 19-minute highlight from their set at Woodstock [YouTube
link]. Today's "Dark
Star" is a prelude to our
commemoration tomorrow of a fundamentally bright cosmic event in human history.
Posted by chris at 12:01 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Music | Politics
(Theory, History, Now) | Remembrance
Song of the Day #1703
Song of the Day: Evil
Ways, words and music by jazz
guitarist Clarence "Sonny" Henry, was originally recorded in 1967 by
jazz percusionist Willie
Bobo [YouTube link] for his 1967 album "Bobo
Motion." It was later recorded by the group Santana,
led by Mexican American Carlos
Santana, who pioneered a fusion of rock and roll with Latin jazz. Gregg
Rolie provides both the vocals and the Hammond
organ solo. The song appears on the
band's self-titled debut album, which was released on August 30,
1969, only two weeks after their performance
of it at the Woodstock Festival [YouTube link] on August 16th. "Evil
Ways" wasn't released as a single until December 30, 1969, becoming
the group's first Top 40 and Top 10 hit. Check out the the
really cool, studio version, as well as covers by the
Village Callers, Johnny
Mathis and jazz
saxophonist Stanley Turrentine [YouTube links].
Joao Gilberto, RIP
I learned earlier today that Joao
Gilberto, who, along with Antonio
Carlos Jobim, was one
of the most important figures in the creation of the sounds of samba and bossa
nova, died
yesterday at the age of 88. He was one of my all-time favorite
artists. In fact, his trailblazing album with jazz saxophonist, Stan
Getz, "Getz/Gilberto,"
would go on to win the 1965 Grammy for Album
of the Year, Best
Jazz Instrumental Album, Individual or Group, and Best
Engineered Album, Non-Classical. Its famous single, "The
Girl From Ipanema," which featured vocals in Portuguese from Joao and
in English from Joao's wife, Astrud
Gilberto, would go on to win the 1965 Grammy for Record
of the Year. The album remains one of my all-time favorites---one of
those recordings that, if necessary, I would take to a Desert Island with me. I
couldn't put up a "Song of the Day" in honor of Gilberto, because I've featured
him so much on "My
Favorite Songs." Among the songs that I have highlighted through the
years, featuring Gilberto's magic touch, check out:
"The
Girl from Ipanema"
[listen here]
"So
Danco Samba"
[listen here]
"Quiet
Nights of Quiet Stars (Corcovado) [listen here]
"Desafinado"
[listen here]
"O
Grande Amour"
[listen here]
"Vivo
Sonhando"
[listen here]
"Bim
Bom"
(written by Joao) [listen here for
Joao's version and here for
the classic Brasil 66 recording of it]
"Para
Machuchar Meu Coracao (To Hurt My Heart)"
[listen here]
"Meditation"
[listen here]
There are so many others... just type his name in "YouTube" and you'll be
introduced to a world of musical genius.
Posted by chris at 04:40 PM | Permalink |
Posted to Music | Remembrance
Song of the Day #1702
Song of the Day: Ball
and Chain was a hit record in the early 1960s for its writer: Big
Mama Thornton [YouTube link]. It was later recorded by Janis
Joplin in 1967-1968 with Big
Brother and the Holding Company for the 1968 album "Cheap
Thrills" [YouTube link], which went to #1
on the Billboard Hot 200 Album Chart. She performed the bluesy song
famously at Monterey
Pop and as
the finale to her own set at Woodstock [YouTube links].
Song of the Day #1701
Song of the Day: The
Star-Spangled Banner features lyrics taken from an 1814 poem
by Francis
Scott Key, "Defence
of Fort M'Henry," written during the War
of 1812, with music based on a popular British drinking song written
by John
Stafford Smith for the Anacreontic
Society, a men's social club for amateur musicians. In truth, my
personal all-time favorite "patriotic" song remains "America
the Beautiful" (especially as delivered by the great Ray
Charles [YouTube link]). Quite apart from the controversies that have
surrounded the
U.S. national anthem over the years (and to all my 'anarchist'
friends, chill a moment!)---from those who claim
that one of its rarely sung stanzas expresses racist content to those
who have taken to kneeling
during its presentation prior to sports events---I have marvelled at
the way it has been performed by some of the most diverse artists through the
years, including Yankee stadium stalwart, the
late opera singer Robert Merrill, the late
Whitney Houston [YouTube links], who delivered a heartfelt rendition
at the 1991
Super Bowl XXV, and the "controversial" Latin-tinged, acoustic
version performed in
Detroit in Game 5 of the 1968 World Series by Jose
Feliciano [YouTube link]. His version became the first recorded
rendition of the anthem that ever charted on the Billboard
Hot 100 (peaking at #50; Whitney's
version peaked at #20). But in keeping with the theme of our 2019
Summer Music Festival, there remains one truly electrifying instrumental
rendition of the anthem by rock
guitarist Jimi Hendrix, who performed as the last artist to appear at Woodstock [YouTube
link]. To some, this
performance was a sacrilege; to others, it
was a sign of the turbulent and violent era to which it spoke. Hendrix actually
plays a couple of notes from 'Taps'
to drive home the point of a nation at war abroad---and at home. Nearly all the
critical commentators on the event have viewed this as the
most iconic performance of the four-day festival. It reflects both
the fireworks of its time and, in a twist of irony, the fireworks set off on
this day in 1776 when American
rebels---whatever
their own flaws, embodied
in the contradictions of their time---pledged
their lives, fortunes, and sacred honor, in declaring their independence from
the British Empire. A Happy and Safe Independence
Day to all!
Postscript #1:
Context: I'm a native Brooklynite and a lover of film scores.
Having been on the Brooklyn Promenade back in 1983, when there was a fireworks
display to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the opening of the Brooklyn
Bridge, I thought I'd never see a better fireworks display. But the Macy's
Fireworks display tonight, which focused its attention on NYC's East River and
the Brooklyn Bridge, one of the world's great, iconic spans, against the
backdrop of some of the greatest film themes ever written (by everyone from
Alfred Newman and Max Steiner to Elmer Bernstein and John Williams) was one of
the best I've ever seen.
If the program hasn't reached your time zone yet, I'm sure it will be on YouTube
or the NBC site soon. But definitely check it out! You won't be disappointed.
Truly wonderful. (Yes, and they even included the love theme from "The
Godfather." :) )
Postscript #2:
Here is a
link on YouTube, starts about 16 seconds in, from the national anthem
to Alfred Newman's Fox Fanfare to Casablanca (Steiner), and so forth. Somebody
on the YouTube thread objected to "The Godfather" being included. But what's
America without the Family? ;) And don't miss Jennifer Hudson's wonderful
rendition of "Over the Rainbow," which includes the rarely heard opening verse
or that absolutely spectacular John Williams segment. At 55 mins., the fireworks
display is shown again, with an introduction by historian David McCllough,
discussing the Brooklyn Bridge---built by immigrants---completed in May 1883.
Postscript #3 (6
July 2019): Remarkably, one reader interpreted the fireworks display as
symbolizing the destruction of the Bridge. My response was light-hearted, but I
think it made a few essential points. As I stated:
Maybe you need a high-definition television. :) I mean, they were by no means
"covering" the bridge [with explosives]. They were cascading off the bridge like
waterfalls; they were shooting straight out of the cathedral towers of the
bridge. And they were---believe it or not---in complete sync with the
magnificent film score medley; even during the love theme to "The Godfather"
there were red, heart-like shapes forming over the bridge; rainbow colors
accompanied "Over the Rainbow", and "celestial" shapes accompanied the John
Williams segment, and so forth. But as I said: To each his own. I opened the
original thread about this fireworks display with "Context": That I was a native
Brooklynite and a lover of film scores. I was also there when the Grucci Family
celebrated the 100th anniversary of the opening of the Brooklyn Bridge; here is a
link to that fireworks display; Macy's actually adapted the very same
"waterfall" and cathedral firework effects from that celebration, as a paean to
the Centennial display. Why on earth are we debating this display as if it were
a symbol of celebration or nihilism? Inquiring minds want to know...
The reader responded that there was a distinct difference in context between the
1983 display and any displays after 2001. I replied:
Well I appreciate that; but I truly am not interpreting this as some kind of
expression of post-9/11 terrorism. Remember that part of the glory of fireworks
on the Fourth of July is that despite all the explosives, the iconic image still
stands (whether it be the flag in "The Star-Spangled Banner" or the Brooklyn
Bridge). To me, the effects highlighted the Bridge and its glory; to you, it is
destruction. I just think we should agree to disagree. You're no less a
Brooklynite if you despised the display then or now. Cheers!
Posted by chris at 12:01 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Culture | Music | Politics
(Theory, History, Now) | Remembrance
Song of the Day #1700
Song of the Day: Heart
of Glass features the words and music of Chris
Stein and Debbie
Harry, who as the lead singer of the new wave group, Blondie,
took this song to the
top of the Billboard Hot 100 in 1979. The song is featured on
the band's third studio album, "Parallel
Lines" (1978). Check out the
Stanley Dorfman-directed video, the
12" dance remix, the
Shep Pettibone 1988 remix, and the
Philip Glass "Crabtree" remix. In 2014, Brazilian supermodel Gisele
Bundchen, with producer Bob Sinclar recorded a charity single cover
version of this song; check out the
video. But in my mind, I always hear the voice of Debbie
Harry, who today celebrates her 74th birthday!
Posted by chris at 12:01 AM | Permalink |
Posted to Music | Remembrance